Blog Post by: Karun Tyagi

The fashion industry is at a crossroads, facing a dual imperative: the need to undergo a green transition to mitigate environmental impacts and a just transition to ensure that the shift is equitable and inclusive. These transitions are not just trends but necessary transformations to ensure the longevity and ethical integrity of fashion. Let’s delve into what these transitions mean for the fashion industry and how they can be effectively implemented.

Origins and History of Green and Just Transitions

The concepts of green and just transitions have roots in various social, economic, and environmental movements over the past few decades. Understanding their origins and historical development provides valuable context for their current application in industries like fashion.

The Green Transition: Historical Context

Environmental Movement (1960s-1970s):

• The modern environmental movement began in the 1960s and 1970s, spurred by growing awareness of pollution, resource depletion, and the need for conservation.
• Key events include the publication of Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” in 1962, which highlighted the dangers of pesticides, and the first Earth Day in 1970, which mobilized millions of people for environmental protection.

Sustainable Development (1980s-1990s):

• The concept of sustainable development was popularized by the 1987 Brundtland Report, titled “Our Common Future,” which defined it as “development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.”
• This period saw the emergence of global environmental agreements, such as the Montreal Protocol (1987) to protect the ozone layer and the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro (1992), which led to the creation of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC).

Climate Change Action (2000s-Present):

• The 21st century has seen a heightened focus on climate change, driven by scientific reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and international agreements like the Kyoto Protocol (1997) and the Paris Agreement (2015).
• Businesses and industries, including fashion, began adopting more sustainable practices in response to regulatory pressures, consumer demand, and a growing recognition of the environmental impacts of their operations.

The Just Transition: Historical Context

Labor Movement (Late 19th-Early 20th Century):

• The origins of the just transition concept can be traced back to the labor movement, which fought for workers’ rights, fair wages, and safe working conditions during the Industrial Revolution.
• Labor unions played a crucial role in advocating for workers affected by economic changes, including those brought about by technological advancements and shifts in industrial practices.

Environmental Justice Movement (1980s-1990s):

• The environmental justice movement emerged in the 1980s, highlighting the disproportionate environmental burdens faced by marginalized communities, particularly low-income and minority groups.
• This movement emphasized the need for fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people in environmental policies and decisions.

Integration of Social and Environmental Goals (2000s-Present):

• The concept of a just transition gained prominence in the 2000s as part of a broader recognition that social and environmental goals must be integrated.
• The International Labour Organization (ILO) and other international bodies began advocating for policies that ensure a fair transition for workers and communities affected by the shift to a green economy.
• The Paris Agreement (2015) explicitly recognized the need for a just transition, highlighting the importance of considering the social dimensions of climate action.

Understanding the Green Transition in Fashion

The green transition refers to the shift from environmentally harmful practices to sustainable ones. In the fashion industry, this involves several key changes:

1. Sustainable Materials: Moving from conventional cotton and synthetic fibers to organic cotton, recycled polyester, and innovative materials like hemp, bamboo, and lab-grown leather.
2. Eco-Friendly Production Processes: Implementing processes that reduce water consumption, chemical usage, and carbon emissions. This includes using waterless dyeing techniques and renewable energy sources in manufacturing facilities.
3. Circular Fashion: Adopting a circular economy model where products are designed for longevity, reuse, and recyclability. This involves practices like upcycling, repairing, and reselling garments to minimize waste.
4. Reducing Waste: Implementing zero-waste design techniques and encouraging consumers to buy less but higher quality, longer-lasting clothing.

The Just Transition: A Social Imperative

A just transition ensures that the benefits of the green transition are shared widely and that no group is left behind. In the fashion industry, this encompasses:

1. Fair Labor Practices: Ensuring that workers across the supply chain are paid fair wages and work in safe conditions. This involves transparency in sourcing and manufacturing processes.
2. Community Support: Assisting communities that are heavily dependent on traditional fashion manufacturing to adapt to new, sustainable practices. This might include providing training programs for new skills and economic support.
3. Inclusivity in Fashion: Ensuring that sustainable fashion is accessible to all socioeconomic groups, not just the affluent. This means making eco-friendly clothing affordable and available.
4. Engagement with Stakeholders: Involving workers, communities, consumers, and policymakers in the decision-making process to ensure that diverse voices are heard and considered.

While the green and just transitions are largely complementary, there are instances where they can conflict. Navigating these conflicts is crucial for the fashion industry to achieve both sustainability and social equity goals.

Potential Conflicts

1. Cost and Affordability:
   • Green Transition: Implementing sustainable practices often increases production costs. Eco-friendly materials like organic cotton or recycled fabrics can be more expensive than conventional options.
   • Just Transition: Ensuring fair wages and safe working conditions also raises costs. Passing these costs onto consumers can make sustainable fashion less accessible to lower-income groups, potentially perpetuating social inequities.
2. Technological Displacement:
   • Green Transition: Automation and advanced technologies can improve environmental efficiency but may reduce the need for human labor.
   • Just Transition: This technological shift can lead to job losses, particularly in regions heavily dependent on traditional manufacturing methods, undermining efforts to protect workers’ livelihoods.
3. Supply Chain Transparency:
   • Green Transition: Sourcing sustainable materials often requires building new supply chains, which can be difficult to monitor for fair labor practices initially.
   • Just Transition: Ensuring that all workers in the supply chain are treated fairly can be challenging when shifting to new suppliers or production methods focused primarily on environmental goals.
4. Rapid Implementation vs. Social Impact:
   • Green Transition: The urgency to reduce environmental impact can lead to rapid changes in production methods, sometimes without adequate consideration of social implications.
   • Just Transition: Ensuring that workers and communities have time to adapt to new practices and technologies is essential, which can slow down the pace of environmental reforms.

Linking Green and Just Transitions in Fashion

For the fashion industry to navigate these transitions effectively, it must integrate green and just transition principles. Here’s how:

1. Transparency and Accountability: Brands must be transparent about their supply chains and manufacturing practices. This builds trust and allows consumers to make informed choices.
2. Collaborative Efforts: Companies should collaborate with NGOs, governments, and other stakeholders to create standards and policies that promote sustainability and fairness.
3. Innovation and Investment: Investing in sustainable technologies and practices is crucial. This includes funding research into new materials and production methods, as well as supporting small businesses and artisans who are leading the way in sustainable fashion.
4. Consumer Education: Educating consumers about the impact of their choices and encouraging them to support brands that prioritize sustainability and fairness.

Challenges and Opportunities

While the path to a green and just transition is fraught with challenges, it also presents numerous opportunities:

1. Challenges:
   • High costs of sustainable materials and processes.
   • Resistance from established industry players.
   • The need for consumer mindset shifts towards sustainability.
2. Opportunities:
   • Growing consumer demand for sustainable and ethically-produced fashion.
   • Technological innovations that make sustainable practices more accessible.
   • The potential for brands to differentiate themselves in a crowded market by committing to green and just principles.

Conclusion: A Call to Action

The green and just transitions are not new concepts but have evolved over decades of environmental and social advocacy. Their integration into the fashion industry represents a critical step toward a more sustainable and equitable future. By understanding the historical context and origins of these transitions, we can better appreciate their importance and the need for continued efforts to achieve these goals.The fashion industry stands at a pivotal moment. By embracing both green and just transitions, it can lead the way in creating a more sustainable and equitable world. This requires a collective effort from brands, consumers, policymakers, and other stakeholders. Together, we can ensure that the future of fashion is not only stylish but also sustainable and fair for all.

Image by freepik